Anti-Heroes: the antidote to a self-righteous society?

Anti-Heroes: the antidote to a self-righteous society?

Dec 19, 2021 | Articles, Latest

An antihero is popularly defined as ‘a character in a story without conventional heroic qualities or attributes, like courage or morality.’

That’s a little simplistic.

The true antihero is an unrepentant sinner. He frogmarches himself into his own personal hell. And as you can imagine, we the readers or spectators, aren’t meant to ‘enjoy’ the journey.

We’re meant to be exhausted by it. To learn from it. To see how our own titillation at their desperate excitement and adventure is the same that can thrill us down the wrong road too.

Antihero stories don’t exist for the same reasons as hero stories. They’re just as important, for different reasons.

And I see them as a perennial antidote to self-righteousness – the most common of human projections.

Morals, culture, and self righteousness

Stories about moral or martial heroism exist to highlight cultural ideas, to create symbols of action that we can admire and mimic.

Antiheroes are a different lot. Loki, Francis Underwood, Turin Turambar,… They’ve been around since the dawn of story, and we enjoy them perhaps with a guilty pleasure.

Anti heroes play an important role. We root for them because they tap into deep, human needs. The drive to thrive, to succeed, to win, to outwit.

But we aren’t always sure we should root for them.

That’s because the point of an antihero is to model a different path. Their story is all about the ‘wages of sin.’ The effects of  human freedom gone wrong.

This is why they won’t go away. They never have, and they probably never should.

The more a culture of people become comfortable with the idea of virtue, and consent to agree on acceptable patterns of behavior, the more self-righteous we become.

We can see this soul-state rampant among the first world west – held up as a virtue.

Self-righteousness is marked by an easy willingness to blindly point out the sins and flaws of others. To be unwilling and even unable to realize that we are pointing out our own.

Self-righteous specialists know how to twist and bend the rules of law. How to work and tweak what’s acceptable to get the job done. Pharisees, mafia, narcissists, obsessives, conspiracy activists… all are convinced of our goodness, and the justice of our lives.

We become the ultimate pragmatists, able to make any sacrifice necessary. Laws don’t apply to us. All moral and physical tools are acceptable to get the job one.  Morality is simply the boiling point for a culture of frogs, a façade we maintain to stay undetected.

All of us have a bit of this snake in us. We all have the same flaw. That’s the risk of being free.

But many of us don’t think through the repercussions of our choices. We assume that an unseen choice remains unfelt, unheard, unnoticed.

Some characters, like Yennefer of Vengeberg, or Tyrion Lannister, aren’t antiheroes. They might be, if their stories ended in Season 1, for example. But their stories continue, and we see that they are, instead, flawed heroes.

The drama of justice

The role of an antihero story is to dramatize those repercussions. To shorten timeframes. To compress karma – the effects of bad choice on self, society, and future. To highlight the horrors of fleeing dharma – the responsibility to good action.

That’s why we are gifted personal judgement in the moment of death, the tallying, weighing, and measuring of each moment as we step into eternity. We will comprehend our whole lives in an instant, and finally see the deep, inner thrust of grace, grit, and greed, and how we chose to act.

We are also gifted the universal judgement at the fulfillment of time, when all threads are tied off, and all ripples of effects finally fade into a still standing wave. We can then see the full impact of our secret and social choices, how they interwove and repeated and echoed in the lives of others, both the radiant good ones, and the abortive bad ones.

Stories of antiheroes, like most stories, are about dramatizing judgement before death. They help us see the result of our gleeful murder of friendship, our betrayal of life, our secret selfishness.

We’re not meant to root for them.

Stories are such strange and fascinating things. Whether we like them or not, they are a portal to live someone else’s life, from the inside out. Their lives may be rotted through with all sorts of wormy seams. The question for us is are we learning the lesson, or drawn to serialized antiheroes like moths to a séance?

Antiheroes and flawed heroes

Flawed heroes are one thing. Most adult fiction steps away from our childhood hunger for black and white silhouettes, and descends into the dappled realities of colorful life. But stories where the heroes never learn, and where we never do either, is the fast food of the story world. Pulp fiction has its place, and it is meant to have low expectations.

Take ‘Game of Thrones’ for example. It builds an world unapologetically  rife with men and women teetering between good and evil. And yet, all that isn’t the point of the story.

The chilling emergence of the Night King is the countdown. And all these kingdoms, riddled with every possible sin, has no capacity for truth and compelling action. This series shows how sin is a spiritual AIDS that saps us of everything worthwhile. And yet, out of the morass, some decisions and examples can ring true loud enough to save lives.

It’s a different kind of story to ‘Lord of the Rings.’ It’s for a different audience.

Antihero stories circle a core truth; how prepared are we for the great truths of the world, when we’re incapable of being honest with our own glutting weaknesses? I thoroughly enjoyed the wry horror drama of YOU, because it dramatizes our constant dissatisfaction with the good in our lives. The everturn back to weakness. Antiheroes are the ghosts that should haunt us when we face difficult choices.

The ‘best’ of us

We who are convinced we’re the best are probably the ones who need these stories most.

The Frollo’s from The Hunchback of Notre Dame, the High Sparrows, Nina’s from the Black Swan, are the kinds of people who don’t ‘convert’. They don’t have a capacity to turn from their obsessions, because they have rationalized so much of it into righteousness.

And that’s the drama of those stories. To understand how trauma and trial and theologizing can create syllogisms of sin that bind. A circling snake eating its tail, unable to break  free. The only thing that can free antiheroes from such steel cells and inner prisons is time, and suffering.

They usually have a strange and inordinate capacity for endurance, for cleverness, for outwitting others. The one they are unable to outwit is themselves. And it is critical that we see that.

‘Wherever you go, there you are.’

Antiheroes are the flip side of any story. They are the unrepentant hero who cannot see, refuses to grow, is unwilling to learn.

Own the ending

The challenge with modern stories is that they end too soon. They end before justice is served. Or they don’t stick the landing, the way ‘Billionaire Boys Club,’ ‘Startup’, Hamlet, and the ‘Godfather’ do.

That’s one reason why Tolkien crafted his consummate antihero, his inverse-Aragorn character, Turin Turambar. He was meant to model all of Aragorn’s greatest weaknesses.

Turin flees his family, his responsibilities, his identity. He isn’t bound to any culture, to any morals, to any real life. And he is constantly hunted and haunted by karma and cruel beast like. His routine blindness leads him to terrible choice after choice. His unwillingness to harness himself and master his weakness results in the deaths of myriad innocents. Even his victory over Glaurung is spoiled by a horror that leads to his end.

I’ve learned Tolkien had an addition to Turin’s terrible story, and it ended in the Halls of Valinor. Basically, Heaven. Turin served a sentence and was awarded bliss with his forbears. The entire arc of the story was to show that this life is only part of a greater one, and that we continue after death, and can redeem our lives.

Where does this leave us as Catholic Authors?

I think I’ll quote Jaskier, who makes a comment to Yennefer in S2:E4  of ‘The Witcher’:

“Once upon a time, I would have used this opportunity to call you an empty, lonely, power hungry she-demon, but I’m an artist, Yennefer. It’s my job to put myself in other people’s shoes.’

Whether we write antiheroes, or engage with them in popular culture, we bring a unique insight.

We recognize that ‘there go I, but not for the grace of God, but for my own grit to hold fast to his grace.’

Ps: Game of Thrones is a bit of an exception. Not so much ‘antiheroes’ as ‘flawed heroes.’

Founder of LegendFiction. Geeks over epics, mystics, science, the angelic, & Netflix. Got an idea for a guest post? Send me a note! | Visit my website

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Join the list for the Weekly Digest of interviews and updates!

You might also like:

LegendHaven Convention 2022

LegendHaven Convention 2022

LegendHaven is the free 2022 online convention to meet up with Catholic and Orthodox fiction authors. Ignite  your excitement to write fantastic fiction!

read more
Katy Campbell | Meet the Mentors | Legendmakers

Katy Campbell | Meet the Mentors | Legendmakers

Katy grew up in a family that was always joking around and laughing. “My grandma taught me that humor is a powerful tool for getting perspective, especially when working through difficulties. I brought this value to my writing and have yet to create a story I don’t consider at least a little bit fun. So far, I’ve published four comedy fantasies and have many more in the works! ”

WEBSITE: www.katysfables.com

Q: Favorite fandom/movie series?

This is the worst question ever because there are so many awesome fandoms to choose from. Since I have to choose, I’ll say Star Trek from the original series through Voyager. (None of these new-fangled Star Treks you kids are watching.) My fairies draw a ton of inspiration from Q, the mischievous all-powerful space alien that appears in Next Generation.

Q: What are you writing these days?

Lots of things! I am doing a sequel to my first novel, Love, Treachery, and Other Terrors. A sequel to Rosaline’s Curse, and a new fun fantasy for middle schoolers about a fifteen-year-old girl’s search for her long-lost parents.

Q: Why is LegendFiction a Good Idea?

Because Orthodox and Catholic writers need a place to tell fun stories that reflect their worldview. I mentioned how much I love Star Trek earlier, but numerous episodes depict religious people as superstitious, science haters that need to be defeated. It’s a pretty standard sci-fi trope.

What’s the solution to this? Help religious writers create awesome sci-fi! Their stories might not be explicitly religious, but they also won’t perpetuate anti-christian stereotypes.

Q: What Services Do You Offer?

I offer story coaching for novels and short stories. As I am reading through your story, I will leave inline comments with my real-time reaction and predictions about where the story is going. This will help you understand if your emotional beats are working.
I try to be as specific as possible with feedback whether it’s constructive or praising. So instead of saying, “I like Chapter 6” I’ll say, “I like how you built tension in Chapter 6 by introducing the mysterious stranger. He was really creepy and the way he kept showing up everywhere the hero went got me really on edge.”

Instead of saying, “This section is boring.” I will say, “Cut this section down because it repeats information you gave us earlier in the story.”

Q: What’s your dream audience?

I like working with people who are open-minded, willing to consider my notes even if they don’t end up using them, and people who are willing to ask clarifying questions about my feedback. I also love working with people who have great senses of humor and don’t take themselves too seriously.

Q: What’s one thing that you wish people knew about editing?

Nobody’s work is perfect. All the great books you’ve read went through numerous rounds of editing. Don’t be embarrassed if I catch a mistake in your manuscript. I’ve probably made the same mistake a hundred times. Editing can hurt, but it’s an important part of making your story awesome!

ABOUT THIS SHOW: Legendmakers
Interviews, convos, and community news about LegendFiction, the creative community for Catholic & Orthodox fiction writers! We talk creed, craft, and co-creation, rooted in grit, grace, gods, and dragons. Let’s inspire your faith and your fiction.

ABOUT LEGENDFICTION
The creative community for modern Catholic & Orthodox authors. Discover new worlds, support your favorite authors, share your works in progress! Share your stories for free, or join our private community.
https://legendfiction.com
About: https://legendfiction.com/about/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/legendfictions/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/legendfiction/

FREE COURSE: How to be a Catholic Author
Helping authors write exciting novels, connect faith with fiction, and be a better Catholic! https://legendfiction.com/free-course

read more
Alien worlds, morals, and Markmakers with Mary Woods | LegendFiction

Alien worlds, morals, and Markmakers with Mary Woods | LegendFiction

Mary Jessica Woods was raised and homeschooled in the Chicago suburbs, where she read as many adventure stories as she could get her hands on. At the age of ten, she realized she was doomed to be a writer and has been following the muse ever since. Still seeking adventure, she headed out west to Wyoming Catholic College, where she climbed mountains, rappelled off cliffs, and studied the Great Books.

After graduating summa cum laude with a bachelor’s degree in the Liberal Arts, she returned to the Midwest to work as an editor. Mary also volunteers as an editorial assistant for the literary magazine Dappled Things, and her nonfiction has appeared in America Magazine, Catholic World Report, and First Things. In her mind, she spends most of her time on distant planets or alien spaceships, but she actually lives in rural Michigan.

WEBSITE: https://maryjessicawoods.com/

GET MARKMAKER:
He swore to paint the truth. Now he is living a lie. For the Noxxiin people, tattoos define identity: they commemorate birth, ancestry, accomplishments—even crimes. As a tattoo artist living on an ancient generation ship, Mariikel Serix has sworn to record the truth. So when he becomes an unwilling accomplice in the banishment of an innocent man, he is horrified that he has broken his oath—and his eyes are opened to the misery of the Underbelly, the realm of the outcasts. https://chrismpress.com/books/markmaker/

ABOUT THIS SHOW: Legendmakers
Interviews, convos, and community news about LegendFiction, the creative community for Catholic & Orthodox fiction writers! We talk creed, craft, and co-creation, rooted in grit, grace, gods, and dragons. Let’s inspire your faith and your fiction.

ABOUT LEGENDFICTION
The creative community for modern Catholic & Orthodox authors. Discover new worlds, support your favorite authors, share your works in progress! Share your stories for free, or join our private community.
https://legendfiction.com
About: https://legendfiction.com/about/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/legendfictions/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/legendfiction/

00:00 Why Mary is a Dinotopian Skybax rider
02:35 Mary’s origin story
05:46 Markmaker
11:22 Traditional publishing with Chrism Press
15:13 Faith-inspired fiction
27:00 Mary’s fandoms that influenced Markmaker
33:00 Mary’s writing process & revisions
40:00 How Mary’s growing her brand
44:33 Mary’s 1 minute message to authors

FREE COURSE: How to be a Catholic Author
Helping authors write exciting novels, connect faith with fiction, and be a better Catholic! https://legendfiction.com/free-course

read more
Welcome to LegendFiction (formerly CatholicAuthor!)

Welcome to LegendFiction (formerly CatholicAuthor!)

ABOUT THIS CHANNEL
Interviews, convos, and community news about LegendFiction, the creative community for Catholic & Orthodox fiction writers! We talk creed, craft, and co-creation, rooted in grit, grace, gods, and dragons. Let’s inspire your faith and your fiction.

ABOUT LEGENDFICTION
The creative community for modern Catholic & Orthodox authors. The creative community for modern Catholic & Orthodox fiction authors. Discover new worlds, support your favorite authors, share your works in progress! Share your stories for free, or join our private community.
https://legendfiction.com
About: https://legendfiction.com/about/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/legendfictions/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/legendfiction/

FREE COURSE: How to be a Catholic Author
Helping authors write exciting novels, connect faith with fiction, and be a better Catholic! https://legendfiction.com/free-course

read more

Pin It on Pinterest